Walking with penguins or watching from the deck
Seeing the Martillo Island penguins from Ushuaia comes down to one choice. You either land and walk among them, or you stay on the water and watch from a boat. The walk costs more and comes with rules, while the boat is cheaper and keeps its distance.
Two ways to meet the colony
Among the Ushuaia penguin tours we compare, four reach Martillo Island, and they split cleanly into two camps. Two land you on the island for a guided walk, while the other two keep you on the water.
The walking days cost ~$380 and ~$549, the boat days ~$115 and ~$225. That gap buys you a place among the few visitors allowed onto the island each day.
Walking on Martillo Island
Both walking trips reach the island by way of Estancia Harberton, a ranch on the Argentine shore. A semi-rigid boat makes the short crossing, about 15 minutes on Say Hueque's listing, and a guide leads you along marked trails.
The walk lasts about an hour, with Magellanic and gentoo penguins around you. Places are limited, so book early if a landing is the reason for your trip.
Luna Roja's penguin walk
Luna Roja's walk at ~$380 runs about seven hours with 19 travelers at most and scores 4.6 from 80+ reviews on Viator. The fare covers an air-conditioned vehicle, the boat and the guided walk.
Several costs sit outside it. You pay the Harberton entry on the day, ARS 60,000 in cash or by card when we read the listing, plus a boarding fee in Ushuaia of ARS 6,000. Tips and your way to the meeting point come on top.
Bookings are confirmed within 48 hours rather than at once. The listing also rules the trip out for travelers with back or heart problems, for pregnant travelers and for wheelchair users.
Say Hueque's all-inclusive day
Say Hueque's full day at ~$549 adds a three-hour yacht cruise past the sea lions and Les Eclaireurs lighthouse. A bus then covers Route 3 and Route J to Harberton, about an hour and a half on the road.
The day lasts 9.5 hours and scores 4.5 from 90+ reviews on GetYourGuide. You cannot choose whether the cruise or the penguins come first, because the operator sets the order by availability.

The walk with the most in it
Say Hueque's 9.5-hour day pairs a yacht cruise on the channel with an hour on foot among the Martillo penguins. Pick any day but Tuesday, when Harberton is closed.
Watching from the water
Tolkeyen's catamaran at ~$115 sails for 5.5 hours from the tourist pier and runs along the Martillo shore without landing. Its listing says you see the penguins from afar, so pack binoculars.
Explore Tierra del Fuego's King Crab Route at ~$225 drives you to Puerto Almanza and out to the colony in a Zodiac. It gets closer than the catamaran and includes lunch. Reviews give it 4.9 from 80+.
Other boats sail the same water. Canoero runs a 5-hour penguin catamaran rated 4.5 from 450+ at about twice Tolkeyen's price, and Pingüinos Expediciones sails a Canoero catamaran to Martillo for about the same as Tolkeyen, rated 4.5 from 430+.
Ratings, hours and group sizes for all six trips sit in our Beagle Channel comparison. The two boat options there are the ones with a penguin column that reads "from the boat".
Rules and dates that decide for you
A few fixed facts settle the question for many travelers before taste comes into it. Check them against your dates and your group before you compare anything else.
- Estancia Harberton is closed on Tuesdays, so plan a walking trip for another day
- Only a few visitors a day may land on Martillo, so places on the walks are limited
- Luna Roja confirms bookings within 48 hours, not instantly
- Luna Roja adds two fees in pesos on the day
- The King Crab Route is not suitable for wheelchair users, and neither is Luna Roja's walk
Weather can move or cancel any of these trips. If the port closes, a catamaran listing gives you your money back or another date, and our best time guide covers the months when each species is around.
Getting to the start, and getting out of it
The two boat trips start in very different ways. Tolkeyen's catamaran leaves from the tourist pier in the center, while the King Crab Route picks you up in Ushuaia, with the time sent by WhatsApp or email the day before.
Luna Roja's meeting point is number 410 on Av. Prefectura Naval Argentina, by the tourist dock, and you make your own way there. Say Hueque's day starts at the tourist port, with the bus to Harberton and the boat to the island in the fare.
Free cancellation up to 24 hours before the start applies on the Tolkeyen, Explore Tierra del Fuego and Luna Roja listings. Say Hueque's terms sit on its own listing, so read them before you pay ~$549.
Who should pick which
Choose a walk if being among the penguins on foot is the reason you came this far south. Pick Say Hueque if you also want the channel cruise in the same day, and Luna Roja if you would rather pay less and skip it.
Choose a boat if your budget is tight or an hour on foot is too much for someone in your group. The Zodiac gives the closer view, as our Puerto Almanza page explains, while the catamaran is cheaper and simpler.
If penguins are only part of the plan, a shorter Beagle Channel tour in Ushuaia may suit you better. Our Martillo Island penguins guide covers the colony, and the price page sets all six fares side by side.